Page 45 - Motor Trend (April 2020)
P. 45

COMPARISON


            Unbelievably, it’s (as tested) now $2,005                                                    The Leaf Plus is a Tempur-Pedic
            less than the Leaf Plus and undercuts                                                      passenger car, Dad’s Buick in the lithium
            the Niro by an astonishing $4,715. There                                                   age, with comfy, settle-in seats to glide
            goes the argument that the traditional,                                                    Mom to her regular doctor’s appointment
            experienced manufacturers are more                                                         with minimal grumbling and a hatch that
            efficient at building cars.                                                                 rises to invite the kids’ hockey gear.
              However, electric cars are often a hall    effective price) and the Niro at $39,905        The Niro is a fishbowl-windowed
            of mirrors. Tesla’s federal tax credit       ($2,785 below the Tesla).                     compact SUV—as Kia likes to describe
            is now exhausted. (Way to punish               What you get for these prices are three     it—with a firm (often pitching, even
            successful first movers!) As such,            distinct flavors of automobile. It’s not       pogoing) ride that pays off with nimble
            the Model 3’s as-tested price stays at       one of those perplexing ice cream shop        maneuvering in the hands of a 20-some-
            $42,690. The Kia and Nissan, on the          choices between hazelnut-almond-rum           thing driver’s game-controller reactions.
            other hand, continue to enjoy the $7,500     or coconut-pecan-raisin. This is a              The Model 3 is a low, slinky sport sedan
            tax credit, thus placing the Leaf at         much simpler chocolate, vanilla, and          (remember those?) with a trunk and a
            $37,195 ($5,495 beneath the Model 3’s        strawberry situation.                         fancy French-curve profile that slightly
                                                                                                       compromises rear leg comfort but fabu-
                                                                                                       lously amplifies the driving experience.
                                                    The Model 3’s interior is Zen-like compared to       So let’s swing out the Model 3’s
                                                    the other two, and its screen is multiple times    flush-surface door levers and tug on the
                                                     larger (though we’re not fans of white seats).
                                                                                                       Niro’s and Leaf’s door handles. Which is
                                                                                                       the best mainstream EV for everyday life?



























            Tesla
            Model 3
































                                                                             WHAT YOU GET HERE ARE

                                                                             THREE DISTINCT FLAVORS

                                                                         OF AUTOMOBILE—A SIMPLE


                                                                      VANILLA, STRAWBERRY, AND

                                                                                CHOCOLATE SITUATION.



                                                                                                                APRIL 2020 MOTORTREND.COM  45
   40   41   42   43   44   45   46   47   48   49   50