Page 44 - All About History - Issue 11-14
P. 44

What if…
        GERMANY HAD WON WWI?






























                                                                                                         WWI saw true industrial warfare for the
                                                                                                                      first time in history

                                                                               What would a German victory in World War I have
                                                                               meant for the United States?
                                                                               A dominant Germany in Europe does not pose a direct
                                                                               threat to the United States and given the physical distances
                                                                               involved with the Atlantic it is entirely possible that the United
                                                                               States would simply accept this position. President Woodrow
                                                                               Wilson had been re-elected in 1916 on the basis of having
                                                                               kept the United States out of World War I, but when German
                                                                               submarines start sinking American transport ships on the
                                                                               high seas in early 1917, they are compelled to enter the war. So
                                                                               in the short term, the United States might well have taken the
                                                                               view that this was no threat to it. What might then happen
                                          A company believed to be the Public Schools Battalion   half a century on is an open question, but if Germany had
                                          (16th Battalion), prior to the Battle of the Somme, 1916
                                                                               developed into the kind of powerful, aggressive state most
                                                                               historians think it would, it’s entirely possible it would have
       “ We might well have seen a war against                                 challenged in South and Central America, or it might have
        that kind of German empire […] in a                                    challenged in the Atlantic or the Pacific [Oceans]. We might
                                                                               well have seen a war against that kind of German empire,
        manner not too dissimilar to WWII”                                     going to war with the United States in a manner not too
                                                                               dissimilar to World War II.

        How would it be different?                                                   O The Schlieffen Plan
                                                                                       Germany must decide whether
                                                                                       to try for an immediate outright
                                                                                       victory in western Europe with
                                                    O Declaration of war               their Schlieffen Plan, or engage in
                                                      After Austria-Hungary declares war   a longer war with the Allied nations.
                                                      on Serbia, Germany in turn declares   September 1914
                                                      war on Russia and, two days later, also
                                                      on France. After Germany invades
                                                      Belgium, Britain feels forced to enter
        Real timeline                                 the war as well.                       Real timeline
                                                      1 August 1914


        1914
        O Franz Ferdinand              O Germany offers
          assassinated                   support
          The heir to the                Kaiser Wilhelm
          throne of the                  II offers German   O The Battle of Mons
          Austro-Hungarian               support for Austria-  The British                   Alternate timeline
          Empire, Franz                  Hungary against    Expeditionary Force
          Ferdinand, and his             Serbia. This leads   (BEF) retreats after
          wife Sophie are                to Austria-Hungary   the Battle of Mons
          assassinated while             ultimately declaring   with the advancing
          on a visit in                  war on Serbia on   German First Army
          Sarajevo, Bosnia.              28 July.           making ground.
          28 June 1914                   5 July 1914        23 August 1914
     44
   39   40   41   42   43   44   45   46   47   48   49