Page 13 - Flight International (January 2020)
P. 13

AIR TRANSPORT




                                                                                            Flight-data recorder analysis
                                                                                          shows the aircraft’s ground roll
                                                                                          was 1,860m and it lifted off about
                                                                                          400m from the runway end, over-
                                                                                          flying the upwind threshold at
                                                                                          about 100ft.

                                                                                          SECOND EVENT
                                                                                          The incident involving aircraft
                                                                                            G-EZTD was followed just 14
                                                                                          days later by an “identical” event
                                                                                          as another EasyJet A320 (OE-IJL)
                                                                                          operating to Paris on 7 May took
                                                                                          off 350m from the runway end. It
                                                                                          crossed the threshold at 75ft.
                                                                                            “Robust adherence to proce-
                                                                                          dures is a key defence against
                                                                                          such incidents occurring,” says
                                                                                          the inquiry, pointing out that
                                                                                            pilots often find reduced acceler-
                                                                                         AirTeamImages  ation difficult to recognise.
                                                                                            EasyJet has since taken steps to

                                                                                          issuing a notice to crews clarify-
        In both cases, jets became airborne too close to far end of Lisbon runway after intersection departures  prevent a recurrence including
                                                                                          ing take-off positions from
        INVESTIGATION DAVID KAMINSKI-MORROW LONDON                                          Lisbon’s runway 21, and raising
                                                                                          awareness of the two incidents
        Portuguese airports warned                                                        among pilots.
                                                                                            “We are aware of the report
                                                                                          and fully assisted the AAIB with
        over ‘confusing’ terminology                                                      its investigation,” says the budget
                                                                                          carrier. “The safety of our passen-
                                                                                          gers and crew is always our high-
        AAIB calls for greater clarity after EasyJet has two identical take-off issues in a fortnight   est priority.
                                                                                            “We take events of this nature
           wo identical serious take-off   It states that for “reasons   which would have allowed a   seriously and will always take
        Tincidents within two weeks     described as historic”, the   lower thrust level.    action to ensure we maintain the
        involving EasyJet Airbus A320s     aeronautical information publi-  The crew did not crosscheck   highest standards of safety. As
        at Lisbon have spurred UK   cation for Lisbon refers to runway   the take-off distances available   highlighted in the report we
          investigators to advise Portugal’s   take-off points as “positions”,   from the two positions and, as a     proactively took a number of
        airports operator to stop using     unlike airports elsewhere.  result, failed to detect the error.  safety actions.”
        confusing  terminology  for                              Although the A320 ultimately   It has also engaged with Airbus
          runway departure positions.  MISCALCULATION          departed from the nearby U5   with regard to future potential
          Both incidents involved the   While calculating take-off perfor-    intersection, the available take-off   protective measures.
        aircraft  accelerating  with  mance criteria with the electronic   distance was still only 2,410m –   Although Airbus is developing
          insufficient thrust and becoming   flightbag, the pilots both based   nearly 1,400m less than the full-  a system for the A320 intended to
        airborne close to the far end of   the calculation on the take-off   length runway.  offer protection against incorrectly
        the runway.                   position designated “PSNSTMP”   The incorrect performance cal-  calculated take-off performance, it
          The UK Air Accidents Investi-  (temporary position S), believing   culation meant the A320’s thrust   indicated to the inquiry that the
        gation Branch (AAIB) says an   it to refer to the S1 intersection.  was too low for the departure.   system in its current state would
        A320 bound for London Luton   But this designation actually     Although the captain mentioned   not have warned the crews of ei-
        on 24 April 2019 had intended a   stood for the S4 intersection,   that the take-off roll “felt wrong”,   ther EasyJet aircraft because the
        departure from the S1 intersec-  used for a full-length runway   says the inquiry, full take-off   runway remaining  exceeded the
        tion of Lisbon’s runway 21.  take-off of 3,800m (12,500ft),   thrust was not selected.  forecast take-off  distance. ■




                   Honeywell Aerospace is transforming. Discover how
                                                  Take your career to new levels
                         ƃKIJVINQDCN EQO *QPG[YGNNUJCRKPIVJGHWVWTG
           Start your journey today                 Register your CV and start your job search today
           Register at ,QDU ƃKIJVINQDCN EQO TGIKUVGT
                                                      Start your journey today Register at ,QDU ƃKIJVINQDCN EQO TGIKUVGT
                                                    A CONTENT PARTNERSHIP

        14  |  Flight International  |  28 January-3 February 2020                                      flightglobal.com
   8   9   10   11   12   13   14   15   16   17   18