Page 45 - MGPI_Case_Study
P. 45

APPENDIX A – SIMPLIFIED CAUSAL ANALYSIS

                                                                        Chlorine gas                  Ventilation
                                                                        entered control              design & siting
                                                                       room via intakes
                                                       Operators were
                                                       overwhelmed with
                                                         toxic gas
                                                                      Operators could not   Respirators locked in   Respirators
                                                                       access respirators  lockers

                                                        No automated or
                                                      remotely operated control   Design
                                                        valves at facility
                                      The reaction
                                    was not immediately
                                       mitigated
                                                                      Driver was in cab      Procedures
                                                      Supply on truck not
                                                         turned off
                                                                      Driver was
                                                                    overwhelmed with   Respirators
                                                                       toxic gas


                                                      Emergency shutoff
                                                        on truck not          Training
                                                         activated





                                                                                     Delivery occurred at
                                                                     Operator was distracted        Delivery schedules
                                                                                      shift change

                                                         Operator did not
                                                        observe connection
                                                                       Unloading procedures
                                                                      did not align with operator   Procedures
                                                                          practice
             ~140 individuals
            exposed to chlorine
             gas and 1,000                                                                  Training
             evacuated/SIP


                                      Workers
                                   inadvertently mixed
                                     sulfuric acid &                                                 Procedures
                                      sodium
                                     hypochlorite
                                                                       Unloading procedures
                                                                      did not align with operator
                                                                          practice
                                                                                                      Training
                                                         Driver attached
                                                        hose incorrectly but
                                                         unlocked fill line
                   KEY
                                                                        Same size fill line
                                                                         connections                  Design
                    Event


                  Condition                                             Two fill lines were
                                                                           ~18"                       Design
                                                                           apart

                   Causal
                   Factors
                                                                       No pipe markers at fill
                                                                        lines connections           Pipe Markings



                                                                                          CSB MGPI Processing Case Study   45
   40   41   42   43   44   45   46   47   48