Page 30 - All About History - Issue 16-14
P. 30

What if…
        THE SOVIETS HAD INVADED JAPAN IN WWII?
                                                                                                 Kuril islands
                                                                                                 Russian forces invaded the Kuril Islands in
                                                                                                 August 1945. In our alternative scenario,
                                                                                                 they push on further south to the
                                                                                                 Japanese mainland.

                                                                         Hokkaido
                                                                         The second-largest island in Japan – and
                                                                         largest northern island – falls to Soviet
                                                                         troops as they continue to push south.



                                                                                  Barrier
                                                                                  Japan is divided
                                                                                  into two
                                                                                  separate zones;
                                                                                  a Communist-
                                                                                  controlled north
                                                                                  and a south                  Tokyo
                                                                                  with US troops               The capital city
                                                                                  in charge.                   remains under
                                                                                                               US control. Its
                                                                                                               industry and
                                                                                                               booming post-
                                                                                                               war economy
                                                                                                               sits in sharp
                                                                                               To yo           contract to
                                                                                         Japan                 some of the
                                                                                                               northern Soviet-
                                                                                                               controlled cities.



        A group of US Marines search for
        enemy soldiers during fighting in   more or less willing to support it. The same with Vietnam –   Japan had signed a neutrality pact in 1941, so the Soviet
        Japan in WWII           perhaps the Americans would have felt over-stretched in Asia   Union wasn’t involved in the Pacific theatre of the war until
                                and not have gotten involved in French colonial questions,   August 1945. However, the US had been pushing for Soviet
                                or maybe the possibility of communist spread would have   involvement against Japan since 1942. The Roosevelt and
                                seemed like an even greater threat.            Truman administrations both hoped the Russians could fight
                                                                               the Japanese army in Manchuria and help with the invasion
                                What would have been the US response to the invasion?  of Japan that was planned before the successful test of the
                                The Soviets and Americans were allies in WWII, fighting   atomic bomb. While there were some dissenting voices in the
                                together in the European theatre. The Soviet Union and   US government, by and large the administration supported the
                                                                               idea of Russia joining the fight against Japan and becoming
                                                                               part of the invasion and occupation.
        “ A successful pro-Soviet communist
         Japan would have increased the                                        Would there have been any Japanese resistance to
                                                                               Soviet rule?
         power of the Soviet Union”                                            The Allies expected substantial resistance after surrender,
                                                                               both to occupation on the home islands and to surrender


        How would it be diff erent?                                           O USSR declares war on Japan
                                                                                Japan has been at war with the US and
                                                                                Britain since December 1941, but the
                                                                                USSR only officially declares war on this
                                                                                date. The Soviets march into Manchuria
                                O Pearl Harbour                                 as Japan continues its retreat.
                                  Japan decides to                              8 August 1945
                                  launch a surprise
                                  attack on the
                                  Hawaiian US base
                                  Pearl Harbor. 2,335
        Real timeline             servicemen die.                                            Real timeline
                                  7 December 1941

        1937
                                                                                             Alternate timeline
        O Second Sino-Japanese War begins
          Japan has been expanding into   O Naval battle
          mainland Asia since 1931 and tensions   The Battle of   O Atomic bomb dropped
          with China reach a head with the Marco   Midway, one of the   on Hiroshima
          Polo Bridge Incident as war breaks out.  most important naval   With Germany defeated,     O Soviet Union invades Japan
          July 1937                   battles of WWII,   President Harry Truman                        A decision is made by the
                                      takes place. Japan’s   orders the dropping of the                Soviet hierarchy to press on
                                      plan to draw the US   atomic bomb on the city                    past Manchuria on the Asian
                                      forces into a trap   of Hiroshima. A second                      mainland and an air and sea
                                      fails and they suffer   bomb is dropped on                       assault is followed by a landing
                                      significant losses.   Nagasaki three days later.                 force on Hokkaido.
                                      4-7 June 1942      6 August 1945                                 20 August 1945
     30
   25   26   27   28   29   30   31   32   33   34   35