Page 53 - Motor Trend (April 2020)
P. 53

COMPARISON
                                      2019 Kia Niro Eco                                                        2019 Tesla Model 3
           POWERTRAIN/CHASSIS         Electric (EX Premium)                2019 Nissan Leaf Plus SL            (Standard Range Plus)

           DRIVETRAIN LAYOUT          Front-motor, FWD                     Front-motor, FWD                    Rear-motor, RWD
           MOTOR TYPE                 AC permanent-magnet                  AC permanent-magnet
                                                                                                               AC permanent-magnet electric motor
                                      electric motor                       electric motor
           POWER (SAE NET)            201 hp @ 3,800 rpm                   214 hp @ 4,600 rpm                  283 hp @ 5,100 rpm
           TORQUE (SAE NET)           291 lb-ft @ 0 rpm                    250 lb-ft @ 800 rpm                 307 lb-ft @ 0 rpm
           WEIGHT TO POWER            19.4 lb/hp                           18.0 lb/hp                          12.6 lb/hp
           TRANSMISSION               1-speed auto                         1-speed auto                        1-speed auto
           AXLE/FINAL DRIVE RATIO     8.21:1/8.21:1                        8.19:1/8.19:1                       9.00:1/9.00:1

           SUSPENSION, FRONT; REAR    Struts, coil springs, anti-roll bar;   Struts, coil springs, anti-roll bar;   Multilink, coil springs, anti-roll bar;
                                      multilink, coil springs, anti-roll bar  torsion beam, coil springs       multilink, coil springs, anti-roll bar
           STEERING RATIO             13.3:1                               13.2:1                              10.3:1
           TURNS LOCK TO LOCK         2.6                                  2.6                                 2.0
           BRAKES, F; R               12.0-in vented disc;                 11.1-in vented disc; 11.5-in        12.6-in vented disc; 13.2-in
                                      11.8-in disc, ABS                    vented disc, ABS                    vented disc, ABS
           WHEELS                     7.0 x 17-in cast aluminum            6.5 x 17-in cast aluminum           8.5 x 18-in flow-formed aluminum
           TIRES                      215/55R17 99V M+S Michelin           215/50R17 90V M+S Michelin          235/45R18 98W M+S Michelin
                                      Primacy MXV4                         Energy Saver A/S                    Primacy MXM4 TO

            DIMENSIONS
           WHEELBASE                  106.3 in                             106.3 in                            113.2 in
           TRACK, F/R                 61.4/61.8 in                         60.6/61.2 in                        62.2/62.2 in
           LENGTH X WIDTH X HEIGHT    172.2 x 71.1 x 61.4 in               176.4 x 70.5 x 61.4 in              184.8 x 72.8 x 56.8 in
           TURNING CIRCLE             34.8 ft                              36.1 ft                             38.1 ft
           CURB WEIGHT                3,906 lb                             3,846 lb                            3,553 lb
           WEIGHT DIST, F/R           55/45%                               57/43%                              46/54%
           SEATING CAPACITY           5                                    5                                   5
           HEADROOM, F/R              40.1/37.7 in                         41.2/37.3 in                        40.3/37.7 in
           LEGROOM, F/R               41.7/36.0 in                         42.1/33.5 in                        42.7/35.2 in
           SHOULDER ROOM, F/R         56.0/55.1 in                         54.3/52.5 in                        56.3/54.0 in
           CARGO VOLUME               18.5 (53.0 rear folded) cu ft*       23.6 (30.0 rear folded) cu ft*      14.6 cu ft*
            TEST DATA
           ACCELERATION TO MPH
           0-30/0-40                  2.5/3.5 sec                          2.8/3.8 sec                         2.1/3.0 sec
           0-50/0-60                  4.7/6.2                              5.0/6.5                             3.9/5.0
           0-70/0-80                  8.0/10.3                             8.4/10.9                            6.3/7.9

           0-90/0-100                 12.9/–                               14.0/–                              9.9/12.2
           PASSING, 45-65 MPH         3.0                                  3.0                                 2.2
           QUARTER MILE               14.8 sec @ 95.7 mph                  15.1 sec @ 93.3 mph                 13.5 sec @ 104.9 mph
           BRAKING, 60-0 MPH          123 ft                               123 ft                              128 ft
           LATERAL ACCELERATION       0.80 g (avg)                         0.76 g (avg)                        0.84 g (avg)
           MT FIGURE EIGHT            27.1 sec @ 0.66 g (avg)              28.2 sec @ 0.60 g (avg)             26.4 sec @ 0.69 g (avg)
            CONSUMER INFO
           BASE PRICE**               $44,045                              $43,475                             $40,690
           PRICE AS TESTED            $47,405                              $44,695                             $42,690
           STABILITY/TRACTION CONTROL Yes/Yes                              Yes/Yes                             Yes/Yes
           AIRBAGS                    7: Dual front, front side, f/r curtain,  6: Dual front, front side,      8: Dual front, front side,
                                      driver knee                          f/r curtain                         f/r curtain, front knee
           BASIC WARRANTY             5 years/60,000 mile                  3 years/36,000 miles                4 years/50,000 miles
           POWERTRAIN; BATTERY        10 years/100,000 miles;              5 years/60,000 miles;               8 years/Unlimited miles;
           WARRANTY                   10 years/100,000 miles               8 years/100,000 miles               8 years/100,000 miles
           ROADSIDE ASSISTANCE        5 years/60,000 miles                 3 years/36,000 miles                4 years/50,000 miles
           BATTERY CAPACITY           64.0 kW-hr                           62.0 kW-hr                          50.0 kW-hr
           EPA CITY/HWY/COMB ECON     123/102/112 mpg-e                    114/94/104 mpg-e                    148/132/141 mpg-e***
           ENERGY CONS, CITY/HWY      27/33 kW-hr/100 miles                30/36 kW-hr/100 miles               24/27 kW-hr/100 miles***
           CHARGING RATE, LEVEL 2/    7.2 kW/75 kW (est)                   6.6 kW/100 kW                       7.6 kW/150, 170 kW****
           LEVEL 3 (65-90 DEGREES F)
           L3 CHARGE TIME FROM 20 TO   At 150 kW CCS: 25/32 min            At 50 kW CHAdeMO: 30/45 min         At 72-kW SC: 22/33 min; 150-kW V2 SC:
           100/150 MI RANGE                                                                                    11/21 min; 250-kW V3 SC: 11/21 min

           TOTAL RANGE                239 miles                            215 miles                           250 miles***
           RECOMMENDED FUEL           120, 240 & 400-volt electricity      120, 240 & 400-volt electricity     120, 240 & 400-volt electricity

           *Hatchback and sedan cargo volumes are measured differently and hence are not directly comparable.
           **All prices before incentives and rebates, which vary by region
                                                                                                                 APRIL 2020 MOTORTREND.COM  53
           ***Values reflect latest over-the-air update  ****V2, V3 Superchargers
   48   49   50   51   52   53   54   55   56   57   58