Page 1396 - Hall et al (2015) Principles of Critical Care-McGraw-Hill
P. 1396

CHAPTER 100: Acid-Base Balance  969


                      3.  Bicarbonate ion (HCO )                           As SID becomes less positive, more [H ] is released into the solution,
                                       −
                                                                                                       +
                                       3
                                                                                                                        +
                      4.  Weak acids and their conjugate bases (HA + A  = A ) (A  is the   and acidemia develops. As SID becomes more positive, more [H ] asso-
                                                         −
                                                                  tot
                                                              tot
                                                                                     −
                       total independent variable, and HA + A  are dependent variables.)  ciates with [OH ], forming water, and alkalemia develops. By contrast,
                                                    −
                                                   )                      A ,  composed of  weak  acids,  is  acidifying.  As  A   increases,  the  pH
                                                                                                              tot
                                                                           tot
                      5.  Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (P CO 2      falls, and as A  decreases, such as with hemodilution, the pH increases.
                      6.  Carbonate ion (CO )                                       tot
                                     2−
                                     3
                      7.  Hydroxyl ion (OH )                              RESPIRATORY DISORDERS
                                    −
                      8.  Hydrogen ion (H )
                                   +
                                                                          By definition, abnormalities in P CO 2  are classified as respiratory dis-
                    The difference between the strong cations and strong anions (the strong   orders. SID (and possibly A ) is manipulated by the human body to
                                                                                              tot
                                      , and the total amount of weak acids and their   compensate for chronic respiratory disorders, thus maintaining pH
                    ion difference [SID]), P CO 2
                    conjugate bases ([A ]) are the only independent variables.  All the other   within the normal range (7.35-7.45). SID decreases to compensate for
                                                             1
                                 tot
                    components are, by definition, dependent, including [HCO ], [HA],   a chronic respiratory alkalosis, and SID increases to compensate for a
                                                                −
                                                                3
                    [A ], [CO ], [OH ], and [H ]. Because the concentrations of each of   chronic respiratory acidosis. The physiologic determinants of P CO 2  are
                     −
                           2−
                                 −
                                         +
                           3
                    these six variables are dependent on one or more of the independent   straightforward:
                    variables, we must solve separate equilibrium equations for each. Water           /V
                    itself is minimally dissociated despite the importance of [H ] and can be   P CO 2  ∝ V CO 2  A
                                                              +
                    considered a constant. The six equations are as follows:  where V CO 2  is CO  production and Va is alveolar ventilation. A change in
                                                                                      2
                     Water dissociation:                                  P CO 2  must be explained by one of these factors. Hypercarbia and hypo-
                                                                          carbia usually can be explained easily at the bedside.
                                   [H ] × [OH ] = K  × [H O]      (100-1)
                                     +
                                            –
                                                 1   2
                     Weak acid dissociation:                              ACIDEMIA AND ALKALEMIA
                                     [H ] × [A ] = K  [HA]        (100-2)  Even relative extremes of [H ] are remarkably well tolerated (eg, pH
                                                                                               +
                                       +
                                             –
                                                 2                        7.1-7.7), at least for the short term, in otherwise healthy individuals.
                     Weak acid conservation:                              However, some authors have even suggested that acidemia itself may be
                                                                                                 2
                                      [HA] + [A ] = [A ]          (100-3)  beneficial to critically ill patients.  For example, since acidemia shifts the
                                              –
                                                   tot                    oxyhemoglobin curve to the right, there is better oxygen delivery under
                     HCO  formation:                                      acidemic conditions. Unfortunately, this “benefit” is dubious because
                         −
                         3
                                                                          acidosis also reduces synthesis of 2,3-diphosphoglycerate (2,3-DPG),
                                     +       −                    (100-4)
                                             3    3                       and thus chronically, acidosis does not appear to improve oxygen
                                   [H ] × [HCO ] = K  × P CO 2
                     CO  formation:                                       delivery. Acidosis may produce other salutary effects on the circulation
                        2−
                        3
                                                                                                                 2
                                  [H ] × [CO ] = K  × [HCO ]      (100-5)  that could result in benefit in certain clinical scenarios,  but acidosis also
                                           2−
                                                        −
                                    +
                                           3    4       3                 produces numerous undesirable effects on various systems (Table 100-1),
                     Electrical neutrality:                               and we caution against “permissive acidosis.”
                                                                           This is not to say that we believe that correcting an acid-base disorder
                                                   −
                                    SID + [H ] − [HCO ] −                 is always appropriate. Indeed, the existing evidence does not support the
                                           +
                                                   3
                                    [A ] − [CO ] − [OH ] = 0      (100-6)  use of sodium bicarbonate for the purpose of correcting the pH in most
                                             2−
                                                    −
                                      −
                                             3
                                                                                              3
                     K  through K  represent constants for the individual reactions. Now that   conditions of acute acidosis,  and some animal experiments even suggest
                               4
                       1
                                                                              4
                    we have six equations and six unknowns, we can arrange any unknown as   harm.  However, supporting respiratory compensation when feasible
                    a fourth-order polynomial and solve the equation. In acid-base balance,   and avoiding acidosis when possible seems a prudent course of action in
                    the dependent variable in question is [H ]. Stated less elegantly, there is a   most clinical scenarios. Frequently, when treating critically ill patients,
                                                +
                                                                    , and   it is easy to blur the lines between supportive measures and therapeu-
                    unique value for each of the six dependent variables once SID, P CO 2  tic interventions. Common forms of acidemia may be associated with
                    A  are known so that all the equations can be solved simultaneously.
                     tot                                                  significant mortality because of the disease processes that underlie them,
                     By taking logarithms to base 10 of Eq. (100-4) and rearranging, we get
                                                                                                       +
                    the familiar Henderson-Hasselbalch equation:          not necessarily because of the actual [H ]. For instance, bowel infarc-
                                                                          tion is lethal, and only surgical resection is curative. Treating the lactic
                                                −     × 0.03)}            acidosis without addressing the underlying cause of the lactic acidosis in
                               pH = pK  + log{[HCO ]/(P CO 2      (100-7)
                                      a         3
                     Since this equation is no more or less correct than any of the other five   this scenario is certain to fail. Dissecting out the effects of acidosis itself
                    equations that must be solved simultaneously, there is nothing wrong   from the causes that underlie it is difficult in patients. However, acidosis
                                                                          itself has been shown to produce harm in animal models —especially
                                                                                                                   5-8
                    with using it to determine an acid-base disorder. Indeed, the fact that   in  models of  sepsis,  where  decreased survival time and hypotension
                    all three values are readily available from a standard arterial blood gas   appear to be attributable to exogenous acid loading.  Nonetheless, it has
                                                                                                              7,8
                    determination explains the popularity of this equation.
                                                                          yet to be demonstrated that treating acidosis per se improves outcome.
                    METABOLIC DISTURBANCES                                SPECIFIC METABOLIC DISORDERS
                    By examining Eq. (100-7) it is possible to determine whether an acid-  To diagnose a disorder leading to a change in SID, an actual account-
                                                                     ) or   ing of strong ions occurs. A decrease in SID may be brought about by
                    base disturbance is present and whether it is due to respiratory (P CO 2
                    metabolic [HCO ] derangements. One might assume, therefore, that pH   the generation of organic strong anions (eg, lactate and ketones) or the
                                −
                                3
                                                              −
                    is determined by the relationship between P CO 2  and [HCO ]. This pre-  loss of strong cations paired with weak anions to balance charge. If
                                                              3
                    sumption is false. Likewise, solving Eq. (100-2) for [H ] does not mean   the patient has diarrhea, he or she is losing [Na ] and [HCO ]; there-
                                                           +
                                                                                                                      −
                                                                                                             +
                                                                                                                      3
                    that [H ] is determined by the HA and A . In truth, [H ] and thus pH   fore, the [Cl ] will increase relative to the [Na ], leading to a decrease in
                                                  −
                                                                                                          +
                                                            +
                                                                                  −
                         +
                                    , SID, and A . Since we define respiratory disor-  SID and, ultimately, acidosis.
                    are determined by P CO 2  tot
                                      , metabolic disturbances are brought about by   The organs of the gastrointestinal tract are underappreciated regula-
                    ders by alterations in P CO 2
                    changes in SID and A . They are not caused by changes in [HCO ], but   tors of acid-base balance. Their ability to manipulate SID complexly
                                                                   −
                                                                   3
                                   tot
                    rather, changes in [HCO ] occur as a result of the disturbance.  is a direct result of the fact that strong ions are handled differently in
                                     −
                                     3
            section08.indd   969                                                                                       1/14/2015   8:28:25 AM
   1391   1392   1393   1394   1395   1396   1397   1398   1399   1400   1401